However, there are some weak points in the book. Although Lubrano acknowledges that Straddlers can come from the city or rural areas, since he grew up in Brooklyn, he tends to focus in on those who come from the city. He could have sought out more Straddlers to interview who grew up rural poor to get a firmer grasp on what their life experiences are like. There are some subtle differences between city and rural blue collar. Similarly, Lubrano mostly interviews people of the same generation as himself.
He conducts one series of interviews with three people from a younger generation, but primarily he interviews people from the same age-range. Similarly, the book came out in , and an updated edition would be nice. Overall, this is an engaging read that addresses the sociological issue of moving from blue collar to white collar class. Interviews with both Straddlers and experts brighten and enlighten the text, although the book would benefit from a bit more variety in the Straddlers interviewed.
Recommended to anyone who is a Straddler themselves, as well as those who may educate or work with Straddlers and those with an interest in class differences.
ISBN 13: 9780471714392
Buy It. What a cool topic! It was such a fascinating read, it was quite a bit of work to compile all of my thoughts on it. I only wish Lubrano had addressed those of us who are artists of some kind or another. You are commenting using your WordPress. You are commenting using your Google account. You are commenting using your Twitter account. You are commenting using your Facebook account. Notify me of new comments via email. Notify me of new posts via email. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
Sign me up! Opinions of a Wolf Honest book reviews to help you quickly find the right read for you or a gift for another.
Limbo: Blue-Collar Roots, White-Collar Dreams
Like this: Like Loading Categories: Book , Genre , nonfiction , Review Tags: alfred lubrano , Blue collar , book , child rearing , class , class mobility , college , culture clash , genre , limbo , limbo: blue-collar roots white-collar dreams , nonfiction , relationships , Review , social class , sociology , Straddler , straddlers , white collar , work. Comments 4 Trackbacks 0 Leave a comment Trackback.
- Un enciclopedista romantico: Psicoanalisi e società nell’opera di Otto Fenichel (Script) (Italian Edition).
- Les âmes rivales (KER.THRIL.POLIC) (French Edition).
- Exploring Initiative and Referendum Law: Selected State Research Guides.
Leave a Reply Cancel reply Enter your comment here Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:. Email required Address never made public. Name required. RSS feed. Email Subscription Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Join 1, other followers Sign me up!
Library Resource Finder: Table of Contents for: Limbo : blue-collar roots, white-collar
You may check out a complete list of my publications here. Featured Quote "Is all very well thinking everything is going to be different when you come back but then it is all the same. Suppose I have to make it different.
Had to substitute arugula for sorrel and peppercorn from cambridgenaturals for juniper berries. Chapters focus on growing up in working-class families, the difficulty of escaping those families to gain an education, the problems working-class students face in college, significant events in the lives of Straddlers when they are introduced to the middle and upper classes for the first time, changes in identity, issues in the workplace, the continuing relationship with families, the problems Straddlers face in marrying and starting families, and the ongoing nature of the struggle with identity.
In each of the eight chapters of the book, he tells his own story and then similar stories of other Straddlers. Many of the stories are moving and emotional.. Straddlers often face difficult decisions in leaving the comfort of their neighborhoods to enter the foreign worlds of college and their chosen profession. Some have to openly defy parents who deny them the opportunity to gain an education.
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Straddlers realize that they have to reject their past at some level in order to move into the middle class. However, they often do not feel as though they fit into the middle-class world; they often feel that they are imposters who will be discovered and sent back to their blue-collar roots where they belong. They often have a hard time functioning at work because the expectations of the working class and the middle class are very different.
They have to learn a new set of rules for survival, and those new rules are often a rejection of those learned while they were growing up. Many Straddlers choose to become academics. Lubrano's research findings agree with previous studies of working-class children who become professors, such as those by Jake Ryan and Charles Sackrey, Strangers in Paradise: Academics from the Working Class Lanham, Md. Project MUSE promotes the creation and dissemination of essential humanities and social science resources through collaboration with libraries, publishers, and scholars worldwide. Forged from a partnership between a university press and a library, Project MUSE is a trusted part of the academic and scholarly community it serves.
Built on the Johns Hopkins University Campus.
go here Jan 06, Fayth rated it it was amazing. I am a first-generation college graduate and a complete mystery to many of my blue-collar relatives. I have a very loving family, but my college pursuits were perplexing to my family. After I left college and began my career, my income illustrated that maybe all that college stuff was worth something. My years-younger brother now has the benefit of I am a first-generation college graduate and a complete mystery to many of my blue-collar relatives.
My years-younger brother now has the benefit of parents who think college is wonderful. All that aside, Lubrano's book was like a mini-visit with a counselor. I found myself saying "YES!
That's exactly how it was! I read this several years ago but it seriously changed my life and the ways in which I interact with my family. View all 4 comments. This is one of my favorite books. It is about how individuals deal with their own social mobility in the United States. I wondered why I felt so uneasy after moving to the city and getting a good job after putting myself through college and grad school. Lubrano gives case studies and analyzes the experiences of those people like me who came from modest roots, but got a good education, a little bit of money, and some broader cultural exposure.
He writes and I agree that people like this still This is one of my favorite books. He writes and I agree that people like this still feel ties to both worlds - where they came from and where they went - never fully belonging to one at the exclusion of the other. All in all the book didn't give me any easy answers about how I should proceed, but did awaken me to the fact that the conflicted feelings i had were being experienced in nearly the same way by a tide of people in similar situations.
Find a copy in the library
I never realized that the things I stumbled, fought, and struggled to learn about how to get a good education, job, professional contacts, sophisticated interests were not such a struggle for people who had affluent, educated families and communities behind them all along. I just figured that the only difference between myself and the Yale kids was money. It's a totally different set of experiences, mentality and environment.
- Limbo: Blue-Collar Roots, White-Collar Dreams | Literary Arts | Pittsburgh | Pittsburgh City Paper.
- Limbo : Blue-Collar Roots, White-Collar Dreams - tiastenhidnews.tk?
There is a huge group of people from places like my rural Pennsylvania that never got that, so when they achieve success, bring a different perspective to the table. I think it's productive, even if it's hard for both sides to adjust to one another. I could identify with something on almost every page. So many stories and statements mirrored my own experience that I had to remind myself that I didn't get them from reading the book and our collective experiences were just that similar.